Pretrial, Fines & Fees

THE ISSUE. Pretrial incarceration occurs when someone who has yet to be convicted of a crime is locked up while awaiting trial. Jail stays can range from a few days to a few years depending on the backlog of cases. Pretrial incarceration was originally purposed with detaining defendants who present a legitimate threat to public safety or who have a track record of failing to appear for court dates. However, it’s now largely determined based on inability to pay fines or fees such as monetary bail, traffic tickets, or court fees. 

THE IMPACT. Taxpayers are footing the bill for jail stays that often times have an adverse effect on public safety. Research shows that, especially in regards to low-risk defendants, even brief jail stays can increase the chance of committing another crime in the future. A contributing factor for this is that a few days in a cell can lead to being laid off, losing housing, making it difficult to find and keep meaningful employment.

When someone who has mental health issues is locked up pretrial it can compound their situation. The same can be said for people who display signs of substance abuse.

Lastly, this can also create a vicious cycle of court debt. Once someone is locked up because they are unable to afford a fine or fee, they tend to rack up additional costs that are attached to court proceedings. Failure to pay this debt can result in more jail time for an indigent individual while defendants with thicker wallets are able to walk free.

Ability to pay a certain amount of money is not a strong predictor of intention to show up in court, nor does it reveal the level of risk of committing another crime.

— Public safety must be placed at the forefront of the criminal justice system by determining pretrial incarceration based on risk. Judges can gain a bigger picture of each individual and make decisions on a case-by-case basis if they utilize risk assessment tools that take criminal records into account.
— Indigence should be considered when assigning fines or fees.
— Give police officers the option to divert low-risk defendants with mental health or substance abuse issues to treatment programs rather than jail.
—Offer alternatives to incarceration for unpaid fines or fees such as payment plans, community service, and digital court reminders.

It’s time for the government to get off taxpayers’ lawns

Katie Greer | June 22, 2018
This article by Katie Greer originally appeared in The Hill June 21st, 2018. Owning a home is a cornerstone of the American dream. Homeownership can feel extremely freeing and…

Rural America isn’t exactly the most ‘free’

Katie Greer | June 19, 2018
Rural areas carry a sense of freedom that’s distinct from the city life. People typically move to the outskirts to get away from urban environments where curtains and walls…

Cash Bail: Putting a Price on Freedom

Elain Ellerbe | June 13, 2018
Across the U.S. presently, several states are tackling controversial issues related to their bail systems.  Right on Crime has advocated for reforms to the bail system that would tie…

Fund courts properly to avoid burden on taxpayers

Elain Ellerbe | June 5, 2018
This article by Elain Ellerbe originally appeared in The Advocate June 4th, 2018. In the Legislature’s last session, House Bill 249 passed that allows judges to waive or provide…

Open Roads and Overflowing Jails: Addressing High Rates of Rural Pretrial Incarceration

Right on Crime | May 31, 2018
The decades-long growth in rural pretrial incarceration has taken a toll on taxpayers and individual liberties. The latest research by Marc Levin and Michael Haugen unveils growth contributors and…

Law Enforcement Assisted Diversion (LEAD) Program promotes safety

Currie Myers | May 21, 2018
Ask any sheriff about the issues associated with jail management and you’ll learn about four major issues: safety of the facility, special needs housing, rising costs of psychotropic medicines,…

Justice system should follow Christian principles

Right on Crime | April 20, 2018
This article by Right on Crime signatory and executive director of the Faith and Freedom Coalition, Timothy Head, originally appeared in The Columbus Dispatch April 20th, 2018. The Faith and…

Rethinking how jails work around rural America

Marc Levin | April 20, 2018
This article by Marc Levin originally appeared in The Hill April 20th, 2018. When most of us think of rural areas, we conjure up bucolic images of the countryside…

How Texas is moving to end debtors’ prisons

Katie Greer | April 9, 2018
This article by Katie Greer originally appeared in the Washington Examiner April 9th, 2018.   A Texas mom, Valerie Gonzales, was thrown in jail because she couldn’t afford the…

Less is more when it comes to putting people in jail

Kurt Altman | March 16, 2018
This article by Kurt Altman originally appeared in Arizona Capitol Times, March 16th, 2018. As someone who has lived in Phoenix since the early 1990s, I have always had…

Listen: Money Bail and Pretrial Detention

Katie Greer | November 10, 2017
The Federalist Society hosted a teleforum on money bail and pretrial detention with Right on Crime’s Marc Levin and John-Michael Seibler of the Heritage Foundation. Levin outlined the financial…

Bringing Balance to Pretrial Proceedings: Solutions for Early Representation of Indigent Defendants

Marc Levin | May 1, 2015
Introduction In recent years, there has been a surge of interest in Texas prison reform. Prison, however, is just one component of the criminal justice system. It is jails,…
Connect With Right on Crime
STAY Informed: