New York

New York, like virtually all other states, experienced a sharp increase in crime and the prison population from the 1970’s to the late 1990’s, but since that time New York is unique among the large states to have experienced both a substantial drop in its prison population and crime rate. Much of this has been attributed to the innovations in policing in New York City under then Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, including COMPStat, a method of data-driven policing that facilitates quick responses to hot spots and holding commanders accountable for results in their region. In fact, from 2000 to 2007, New York City’s reduced its violent crime rate by 64 percent and incarcerated 42 percent fewer offenders.i

In 1977, New York prisons housed 20,000 offenders; by 1999, there were 73,000.ii After 2000, however, New York began a year-by-year drop in its prisoner population, bucking the national trend of continued (though moderate) growth. By 2008, New York prisons held 60,000 inmates—a 16 percent fall from a decade earlier.iii

From 1965 through 1991, property crime in the United States and New York tracked closely together, each about doubling.iv After 1991, the property-crime rate fell both statewide and nationally, but more rapidly in New York. In 2008, the property-crime rate in New York (2,000 crimes per 100,000 residents) was 1.6 times lower than in America as a whole (3,200 per 100,000 residents).v The same pattern holds for violent crime. By 2008, the violent-crime rate was considerably lower in New York State (400 per 100,000) than in the United States (450 per 100,000).vi

In their budget recommendations to state lawmakers , The Empire Center for New York State Policy called for consolidating partly empty prisons, rather than keeping unneeded prisons open to avoid cutting government jobs, and expanding the use of alternatives to incarceration that cost-effectively reduce recidivism among nonviolent offenders.vii

i Marc A. Levin, “Thinking Outside the Cell: Ten Truths About Texas Criminal Justice,” Texas Public Policy Foundation, Sept. 2010, http://www.texaspolicy.com/pdf/2010-09-CEJ-PowerPoint-ml.pdf.
ii Bert Useem, “New York’s Prison Turnaround,” City Journal, Summer 2010, http://www.city-journal.org/2010/20_3_snd-ny-imprisonment-rates.html.
iii Ibid.
iv Ibid.
v Ibid.
vi Ibid.
vii “Blueprint for Better Budget: A Plan of Action for New York State,” Empire Center for New York State Policy, 4 Jan. 2010, 12 May 2010, http://www.empirecenter.org/Documents/PDF/Blueprint-Final17.pdf.

Crime Surge! — Blood, Well-Told Half-Truths, And Statistics

Chuck DeVore | October 8, 2015
This commentary originally appeared in Forbes on October 7, 2015. In the wake of urban unrest in Ferguson and Baltimore a particular meme has developed that crime is spiking. From the…

Marc Levin Speaks At FreedomFest About Barriers To Reentry

Greg Glod | July 14, 2015
This past Friday, Marc Levin, Center Director for the Center of Effective Justice and Right on Crime, spoke on a panel at FreedomFest in Las Vegas that focused on…

Nation’s Largest City Launches Initiative To Reduce Pre-Trial Incarceration

Michael Haugen | July 9, 2015
In an effort to address the significant number of accused offenders waiting in jail before their trial date, New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio has announced a new program…

Treating Kids as Kids to Help Curb Crime

Right on Crime | March 20, 2015
Former House Speaker and Right on Crime signatory Newt Gingrich took to the New York Post to urge support for New York State’s juvenile justice reforms. Taxpayers are entitled…

Reducing Inmates Can Reduce Crime

Marc Levin | March 3, 2015
Marc Levin, Policy Director of Right on Crime, engaged in the “Room for Debate” discussion in the New York Times: Every week, 220,000 Americans enter local jails, with about…

New York Violence Against Youths

Right on Crime | October 9, 2014
Very few states charge 16- and 17-year-olds as adults, but New York is one of them. And now these much younger individuals are learning violence from those already proven…

Closing the Door to Prison, Opening the Door to Reform

Right on Crime | October 31, 2013
While New York isn’t exactly a beacon of liberty, it has been pursuing sensible criminal justice reform over the past few years. Reforms in 2009, for instance, softened mandatory…

Former Prisoners turned Entrepreneurs through Private Programs

Right on Crime | September 28, 2012
Defy Ventures describes its program as “MBA-like training, real business plan competitions, and real money.” While such a program would likely grab the attention of many would-be-entrepreneurs, the unique…

A Right Way and A Wrong Way to Reduce Prison Populations

Right on Crime | July 10, 2012
Research has revealed that there is a right way and a wrong way to reduce the population of defendants and inmates who are securely confined: categorical releases are usually…

Community-Connected Probation

Right on Crime | June 22, 2012
New York City is attempting to create a more effective probation process and to move probationers through the system more expediently. By using “Neighborhood Opportunity Network” offices, or NeONs,…

Targeted Approaches to Juvenile Justice

Right on Crime | May 25, 2012
Unique circumstances sometimes underlie juvenile delinquency cases. In order to properly handle those cases and prevent further wrongdoing, targeted approaches can specifically address those underlying circumstances in ways traditional…

Jobs for Inmates In and Out of Prison

Right on Crime | April 5, 2012
For a prisoner exiting the corrections system, the ability to secure steady employment may determine whether he or she is able to successfully reenter society and begin a productive,…
Connect With Right on Crime
STAY Informed: